Thursday, July 31, 2014

Where My Ladies At?

I view myself as a feminist. Am I a man-hater? Am I lesbian? Am I crazy?!


No! It just means that I believe in equal rights for every single human! Because guess what? Those stereotypes are exactly the reason that it's important to have equality. The things Sarah Vowell taught me about the Puritans who settled America got me thinking about how truly deep-rooted the attitude of not only misogynism, but of native oppression in our country from the very beginning. It's all about the True Entitlement of the Great White Man.


"Fight the patriarchy!" they say. Patriarchy means "the rule of the father", and if pater is Latin for father, and to the Puritans Father was representative of God, then equality is the last thing on their minds. Then again, these Puritans were Pope-hatin' pious folks. If the Pope is the father, then perhaps they could be convinced of the idea in some roundabout manner.


It's clear the Vowell is a fan of the more modern rights that we have, and much less of a fan of the attitude “She is either male property (Mrs.), wannabe male property (Miss), or man-hating harpy (Ms.),” writes Vowell in a spew of I-am-bothered-about-the-state-of-things. Her adoration of Anne Hutchinson, the only strong female in the whole of New England, was annoying at times although it gave me more perspective on the lack of gender equality. Hutchinson was able to attract many people to her ideas even as a mother of twelve children, and she was both smarter and more in the right than her prosecutors at her trial.


Vowell also made it very clear that it was despicable how the New Englanders felt about the Native Americans, and how they treated them. Even the illustration at the very beginning of the Massachusetts Bay Colony seal saying "Come over and help us." Seriously? Seriously? These Puritans, these self-hating, god-loving (or perhaps fearing) people have this feeling that these perfectly happy and self-sufficient people need their help.


Winthrop could certainly have benefitted from a healthy dose of equality. He seemed like the sort of man who, if approached in the right way, could have changed his mind and fought for equality. He considered himself of high moral standing, and perhaps having such a cause would have fed his mind and given him energy. He certainly proved that he could fight for causes. The only problem is that no matter how far we seem to have come from these times of early white America, we still have so far to go.

5 comments:

  1. Good points here! A couple things that came to mind: About the Native Americans: I think we need to consider whether the attitude of "Come Over And Help Us" is something that just the Puritans have, or is it all missionaries? It's also hard to make judgements about people who lived in a time where people weren't taught that all humans are equal. It doesn't make what they did any less wrong, it just puts things into context a little bit.

    ReplyDelete
  2. You have a lot of good points here, but I kind of understand where the the "come over and help us" attitude if the Puritans comes from. Not that I agree with, but it may not be as ridiculous as it seems. First of all the native Americans were not as well of you say they were. Nine of of ten of them were recently killed by disease. I don't think I would be perfectly happy if nine tenths of everyone I knew suddenly died. Also, even if the Native Americans were happy in this life, the Puritans thought they were all doomed to hell. The "come over and help us" belief may have been more focused on the Puritans belief in eternal salvation for the Native Americans. I do want to end with a little disclaimer; I not condoning the Puritans "helpful" beliefs, because they seemed to just be a justification for helping themselves to some Native American land.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. nine out of ten of them were killed by diseases BROUGHT OVER BY THE SETTLERS

      Delete
  3. Anna,
    With respect to this statement:"It just means that I believe in equal rights for every single human." This makes you certifiably crazy. Just thought I would let you know, so you can rest easy.

    ReplyDelete